The 1911 has the second highest mintage of any date in this series. It is the most common date from the 1910’s in terms of its overall rarity, (i.e., the total number known to exist) but it is a very rare coin in the higher Uncirculated grades; nearly comparable to such better known issues as the 1912 and the 1913.

The obverse strike is sometimes reasonably sharp, but more often than not there is weakness on the three lower feathers, parts of the headdress and on the brow. The reverse is not quite as sharp as on the 1909 and 1910 issues and some coins are not fully detailed on the eagle’s breast and the upper portion of the wing, near the neck. Any coin that is sharply struck on the obverse and reverse should sell for a premium.

Scarcity, Surface Imperfections, and Desirable Luster

The 1911 Indian Head Quarter Eagle is a very scarce coin in the higher Mint State grades. This is due to the fact that most have numerous small marks on the surfaces. It is not uncommon to see pieces with mint-made copper spots as well.

The luster is below average. It is most often very grainy in texture. Any example that has appealing, undisturbed luster is extremely scarce and in great demand among date collectors.

The coloration is frequently a medium to deep greenish-gold with some orange-hues mixed in. A small number of 1911 Quarter Eagles show natural light yellow-gold color and this appearance tends to be considerably more attractive than the look mentioned above.